Skip to main content
Education only. ClearMoneySchool does not provide individualized investment, tax, or legal advice. Why we don't give advice →
S&P 5007743.41+0.51%NASDAQ 10030,608+0.42%DOW51,829+0.93%RUSSELL 20002837.55+0.07%VIX14.87-5.11%GOLD$4320.50+0.52%SILVER$64.71+1.11%BITCOIN$84,059-0.29%
Live · 60s
8 indices tracked · Quotes may be delayed up to 15 minutes · As of 7:19 PM ET

Most Contracts Contain a Clause Saying Nobody Has to Perform If Something Big Enough Happens

Near the end of most contracts sits a clause that can excuse a party from its obligations when something outside its control intervenes. It is called force majeure, it appears in a great many ordinary agreements, and most people have signed several without ever reading one.

· Listen

Download MP3
0:000:00

The simple version

A contract is a set of promises with consequences attached if you break them. Near the end of most contracts sits a clause saying some of those promises pause if something large enough happens.

It is usually called force majeure. The phrase turns up in leases, gym memberships, event tickets, construction agreements, and ordinary service contracts.

The numbers

  • Cornell Law School's Legal Information Institute defines force majeure as a provision in a contract that frees both parties from obligation if an extraordinary event directly prevents one or both parties from performing (Cornell Law School, Legal Information Institute)
  • The same source states that a non-performing party may use the clause as an excuse for circumstances beyond that party's control and not due to any fault or negligence by it (Cornell Law School, Legal Information Institute)
  • It also states that mere impracticality or unanticipated difficulty is not enough to excuse performance (Cornell Law School, Legal Information Institute)
  • And that courts generally do not recognize economic downturn as a force majeure event, because economic hardships occur regularly in business (Cornell Law School, Legal Information Institute)
  • This article carries no figures, because the clause is a mechanism rather than a measurement, and contracts are governed by the law named in the agreement, which differs from state to state (stated limitation)

What the clause actually does

Ordinarily, failing to do what a contract requires is a breach, and breach has consequences. Damages, termination, sometimes both.

A force majeure clause carves out an exception. If a listed event occurs and it prevents performance, the party who cannot perform is excused rather than in breach. The obligation pauses, or in some drafting ends entirely.

The critical detail is that this is not a background rule of fairness. It is a term somebody wrote into the document, and it does only what the words say.

The list is the whole argument

Force majeure clauses usually contain a list. Natural disasters, war, government action, labor stoppages, and so on. Whether an event is on the list, or close enough to something on it, is where the disputes happen.

Two other tests usually sit alongside it. The event has to have been outside the party's control and not the result of its own fault or negligence, and it has to have actually prevented performance.

That second test does a lot of work. The Legal Information Institute puts it plainly: mere impracticality or unanticipated difficulty is not enough, and courts generally do not treat an economic downturn as a force majeure event.

So a contract that became unprofitable is not the same thing as a contract that became impossible. The gap between those two is where most of the argument lives.

The Real Cost lens on the clause already signed

The clause matters to ordinary people mostly in the direction they rarely think about, which is when the other side invokes it. Here is where it tends to show up.

  • A venue cancels an event, and the ticket terms describe what happens to the money already paid.
  • A monthly service stops delivering for a period, and the agreement decides whether anything is owed back for that period.
  • A contractor cannot get materials, and the agreement decides whose problem the delay is.
  • A lease describes what happens if a building becomes unusable, and for how long, before either side can walk away.

In each case the answer sits in the document rather than in general fairness. That is the practical value of knowing the clause exists: it tells you which page to turn to, and it is almost never the page anyone reads at signing.

What this means

Force majeure is one of the few contract terms that becomes relevant only after something has already gone wrong, which is exactly when nobody wants to be reading a contract. Knowing the name before that day is most of the benefit.

When a company invokes one publicly, the argument that follows is almost always about the same three questions. Was the event on the list, was it outside that party's control, and did it prevent performance or merely make it costly.

What this is NOT

This article explains what a type of contract clause generally does. It is not legal advice, it does not interpret any particular agreement, and it does not tell anyone whether their contract contains such a clause, what theirs means, or what to do about it. Anyone with a live question about their own contract should talk to a lawyer, because the answer depends on the exact wording and on the law governing that agreement, and both vary substantially. This article takes no position on whether any party is entitled to invoke any clause, on whether any invocation is valid or likely to succeed, or on the merits of any dispute, and it names no company and takes no position on any security. The descriptions of how courts have generally treated these questions come from a legal encyclopedia and are general background rather than a statement of the law in any jurisdiction. Nothing here is a substitute for reading the document that actually governs an agreement.

Sources

  • Cornell Law School, Legal Information Institute, Wex entry on force majeure: https://www.law.cornell.edu/wex/force_majeure

Found this useful?

Education only. Nothing here is investment, tax, or legal advice.