Skip to main content
Education only. ClearMoneySchool does not provide individualized investment, tax, or legal advice. Why we don't give advice →

A Bait Offer Has A Published Standard For Whether The Seller Meant It, And It Turns On How Much The Seller Actually Had. One Printed Sentence Settles It.

The standard asks whether there was enough on hand for the demand the seller could fairly expect. It stops asking that if the offer says plainly there is only so much, which is why the phrase is printed on nearly every deep markdown you will see.

Consumer FinanceNovember 21, 2026Edited by Joseph Citizen, FounderUpdated November 21, 2026
Download MP3
0:000:00

The simple version

Bait selling has a settled written meaning, and it is narrower than most people assume. It is an offer to sell something the seller does not actually want to sell, made to draw in people who might buy something else instead.

The document that sets out that meaning is almost sixty years old, and it is written in the language of advice rather than of orders. That turns out to matter less than what it asks for.

What it asks about is mostly stock. Whether there was enough on hand for the demand the seller could fairly expect, and if there was not, whether the offer said so up front.

The numbers

  • The source is 16 CFR Part 238, Guides Against Bait Advertising, read on November 21, 2026 in the 2024 annual edition of the Code of Federal Regulations published by the Government Publishing Office. It is a Federal Trade Commission document.
  • Where it sits, which tells you what kind of document it is. The part appears in title 16 under the Federal Trade Commission, beneath a subchapter heading that reads GUIDES AND TRADE PRACTICE RULES. The part heading reads PART 238 and then GUIDES AGAINST BAIT ADVERTISING.
  • Its own dates and authority. The source line reads 32 FR 15540, Nov. 8, 1967, unless otherwise noted, and the authority line reads Secs. 5, 6, 38 Stat. 719, as amended, 721; 15 U.S.C. 45, 46. The eCFR page for the surrounding subchapter, read the same day, lists Part 238 with sections 238.0 through 238.4 and does not mark it reserved or removed.
  • The wording, counted. Across the whole of this part the word shall appears zero times and the word should appears four times. For contrast, in 16 CFR Part 435, a Federal Trade Commission document that sits under a subchapter heading reading TRADE REGULATION RULES, shall appears 30 times and should three, and no bracketed Guide label appears in it at all. Both counts are ours, measured on the whole-part text of the same 2024 annual edition.
  • The five sections. 238.0 Bait advertising defined. 238.1 Bait advertisement. 238.2 Initial offer. 238.3 Discouragement of purchase of advertised merchandise. 238.4 Switch after sale. Four of them close with a bracketed label reading Guide and a number, running from Guide 1 to Guide 4.
  • What the defining section says the practice is for. Section 238.0 states that the purpose is to switch consumers from buying the advertised merchandise, in order to sell something else, usually at a higher price or on a basis more advantageous to the advertiser, and that the primary aim of a bait advertisement is to obtain leads as to persons interested in buying merchandise of the type so advertised.
  • The footnote that widens the term. A footnote to section 238.0 states that for the purpose of this part advertising includes any form of public notice however disseminated or utilized.
  • The stock condition, which is the line that matters most in a sale week. Section 238.3 lists six acts or practices weighed in deciding whether an offer was genuine, and the third is the failure to have available at all outlets listed in the advertisement a sufficient quantity of the advertised product to meet reasonably anticipated demands, unless the advertisement clearly and adequately discloses that supply is limited and/or the merchandise is available only at designated outlets.
  • The other five acts in that list, in the document's own order: refusing to show, demonstrate or sell the product on the terms offered; running down the product or its guarantee, credit terms, service, repairs or parts; refusing to take orders for delivery within a reasonable period; showing a product that is defective, unusable or impractical for the purpose represented; and paying or penalizing salesmen in a way designed to discourage them from selling it.
  • That selling some does not settle the question. A closing note states that sales of the advertised merchandise do not preclude the existence of a bait and switch scheme, and that on occasions this is a mere incidental byproduct of the fundamental plan and is intended to provide an aura of legitimacy to the overall operation.
  • For two Federal Trade Commission documents that are rules rather than guides, see our pieces on the CARS Rule and on the junk fees rule. For how the size of a marked-down price depends on which reference price it is measured against, see our piece on the crossed-out price.

Why the line about limited quantities is the whole mechanism

A sale price that looks impossible raises one question: did the seller mean it. The published standard answers that mostly by looking at how much was on hand, which is also the part a buyer can see from outside.

It asks whether there was enough on hand at the places named to meet the demand the seller could fairly expect. If there was not, that counts against the offer having been a real one.

There is an opening built into that, and the opening is a sentence. If the offer says clearly that there is only so much, or that it is only in certain places, the question stops counting against it.

Which is why those phrases appear on nearly every steeply cut offer in a sale week. They are not throwaway hedges. They are the words that answer the question.

The actual math on the six-item list

Section 238.3 sets out six acts weighed in deciding whether an offer was real. Exactly one of the six is about how much was on hand.

That one, though, is the only one of the six a buyer could check from outside. The other five turn on what the people selling did or said, on what shape the item was in, or on how those people were paid, and none of that is visible from the aisle.

So one in six by count, and the only checkable one in practice. That ratio and that point are ours; the list and its ordering are the document's own.

One surrounding figure is worth a line. The dated source line on this part reads November 8, 1967, which is 59 years before this piece was written.

What this means

When a sale week fills with prices that look impossible, the published standard for whether an offer was a real one is short and worth knowing. It turns substantially on whether there was enough for the demand the seller could fairly expect, or whether the offer said plainly that there was not.

The second habit is to check what kind of document a quoted line comes from before treating it as the law. Guides and rules sit beside each other in the same title and are written in different words on purpose.

Plain-English takeaway

This article reports what one Federal Trade Commission document says and how it is worded. It is general education and not legal advice, it does not assess whether any seller or any offer complies with anything, and it is not a claim about any company.

What this is NOT

This article reports the text, wording and placement of 16 CFR Part 238, the Federal Trade Commission's Guides Against Bait Advertising, as read on November 21, 2026 in the 2024 annual edition of the Code of Federal Regulations, with the retail sale week that follows Thanksgiving as the occasion for reading it. It is not legal advice, and nothing here should be relied on as a statement of anyone's rights or obligations: a reader with a dispute about a purchase should take it to a lawyer or to the agency, not to this page. It is not a claim that any retailer, seller, advertisement, doorbuster or limited-quantity offer is or is not bait advertising, and no specific advertisement of any kind was examined for this piece. It is not a claim that these guides are unenforceable, toothless or ignorable, and it is not a reading of what legal weight they carry: we report where the document sits, how it is headed, which authority it cites and how its sentences are phrased, and we take no position on how any of it would be applied. It is not a complete account of the part, which is quoted in places and summarized in others. It is not an account of any state's law, none of which was read; state rules on advertising and pricing differ and may add requirements. It is not advice about shopping, spending, borrowing or any purchase, and it recommends nothing. We read the part in a single annual edition rather than in the live eCFR text, and the eCFR page we opened was the surrounding subchapter listing rather than the part itself, so a later amendment would not be visible to us; that listing showed the part present and not marked reserved or removed. Ours are the counts of the words shall and should in this part and in Part 435, the counts of sections and bracketed labels, the one-in-six ratio, the observation about which of the six acts a shopper could check, and the 59 years; every quoted phrase, section number, date and authority citation is the code's own. This is not a political endorsement or criticism of anyone.

Sources

  • U.S. Government Publishing Office, Code of Federal Regulations, 2024 annual edition, title 16 volume 1, Part 238, Guides Against Bait Advertising, at govinfo.gov/content/pkg/CFR-2024-title16-vol1/xml/CFR-2024-title16-vol1-part238.xml, read November 21, 2026, for the subchapter and part headings, the authority and source lines, the five section numbers and headings, the text of sections 238.0 through 238.4, the footnote on the meaning of advertising, the closing note on sales of advertised merchandise, and the bracketed Guide labels. Read as XML in a browser on the publisher's own domain.
  • U.S. Government Publishing Office, Code of Federal Regulations, 2024 annual edition, title 16 volume 1, Part 435, Mail, Internet, or Telephone Order Merchandise, at govinfo.gov/content/pkg/CFR-2024-title16-vol1/xml/CFR-2024-title16-vol1-part435.xml, read November 21, 2026, used here only for its subchapter heading and for the comparison counts of the words shall and should and the absence of any bracketed Guide label.
  • Office of the Federal Register, eCFR, title 16 chapter I subchapter B, at ecfr.gov/current/title-16/chapter-I/subchapter-B, read November 21, 2026, for the listing of Part 238 with sections 238.0 through 238.4 and for the fact that it is not marked reserved or removed.
Receipts2 receipts: the source's own words, with a link to eachShow
  1. Bait advertising is an alluring but insincere offer to sell a product or service which the advertiser in truth does not intend or want to sell
    16 CFR 238.0, Guides Against Bait Advertising, 2024 annual editionRead Nov 21, 2026
    Open the source (opens in a new tab)
  2. it constitutes an unfair method of competition, and an unfair or deceptive act or practice for a seller
    16 CFR 435.2, Mail, Internet, or Telephone Order Merchandise, 2024 annual editionRead Nov 21, 2026
    Open the source (opens in a new tab)

Found this useful?

Education only. Nothing here is investment, tax, or legal advice.